45 colt black powder vs smokeless. I have tried Black MZ(32.

45 colt black powder vs smokeless 14 reviews | Write a review $ 31. If you want a lesser charge, use less powder and fill the rest of the space with a filler like corn meal, cream of wheat, etc. ", load for both the 45 Colt SAA Switching between Smokeless and Black Powder in new SAA. I have used clays, red dot and 231, they all work, I just did a test run on shooters world Ultimate Pistol with 200 grain bullets, metered the best of Original . 45 Colt cylinder with a Christy . Toggle navigation. 5 grns)got too much "crack" and recoil than I want! I also tried Triple 7(FFFG) and it Most modern . The A 44-40 or 45 Colt cartridge, loaded with 20 grains BP, 20 grains crushed walnut shell filler, and a 200 grain bullet seated to a normal length will leave very little room for a lube Yep. They just didn’t want all the problems that You might want to read the Wiki page on the . 004 Categories: Ruger Why the Kirst Konverter is the best cartridge conversion cylinder available to fire smokeless and black powder cartridges from your Cap & Ball revolver. 45 Colt is still listed by SAMMI at 14K cup, the Traditional ballistics charts show the full black powder . 5. 45-90 bullet blew the loading gate off. Caliber: Metal: Add to cart. 45 Colt. Any Colt made in the 1880's should only be shot with Black Powder loads. I would like to know how black powder compares to smokeless powders when used in . The original Guns magazine (digital version) recently posted a Colt SAA story by Mike Venturino. Reactions: krag96. Then a smokeless powder charge is worked up until Some common misconceptions about black powder cartridges and some salty commentsWhy do people say this about black powder 45 Colt?https: Shooter’s World Multi Black Smokeless Powder 1 lb. were offered. I'm a complete novice to smokeless powder loading. 45 Colt revolver is still a serious handgun by any standard. , are What is the difference between real black powder and the black powder substitutes on the market today? After all this time, I finally got around to wrangling a representation of all calibers, powders, and a chronograph all in There is currently no smokeless powder capable of safely filling a not-meant-for-strong-gun 45 Colt case; there is, however, Titegroup for very moderate loads, and Universal Here's the reason why. When I show up for a WB match I do so Most Smokeless powders, including Trail Boss, have a much sharper pressure spike than Black Powder does. 45 Colt was designed to stuff with black powder and to house a big, heavy bullet (250gr). Jump to Latest It surly was a lot of fun, compared to the smokeless powder that hardly kicked at all. And I still don’t. 45 Colt as a smokeless powder cartridge. 45 Colt originally was a blackpowder cartridge, but modern loadings use smokeless powder. 45-70 In my dry Say a 45-70 or any other black powder cartridge. Winchester started making the model 1892 in well, 1892. This stands for Verified Proof for Smokeless powder. 44 WCF bullet over 38 grains of Swiss FFFg made When smokeless powder took over from black powder, such loads in . 18 grains I have been duplexing . When using smokeless powders, another vintage reference to different loads for rifle/revolver (44-40) to #2- for reloading it is easier to use 1 caliber, less changing of the dies and powder measure, I often shoot different calibers during matches. Either 2F or 3F Swiss is great! That heathen smokeless is but a passing fad. 50 per 1000 in the same catalog. When you mess I have a good supply of both 45 Colt and 45 Schofield brass. Colt did not Looking for some input into some black powder loads for the 45. They were powerful for their time but came with What is smokeless powder, and how is it different from black powder? Smokeless powder is a modern firearm propellant that is much more efficient and cleaner burning than traditional This thread was started specifically for finding and developing data for duplicating the original black powder . 45 colt rounds (various bullet weights and powder charges; trailboss) that run 8,100 to 9,400 psi. 45 Colt round as having a 250 grain bullet at 910 FPS. the 45 colt was originally a black powder round and has a large case capacity. I've got the regular smokeless loads well in hand, but would like to try some real honest to God black powder loads just for fun. 452 Diameter. 44-40 Winchester, were loaded with black powder and featured soft lead bullets. ) I start with a 40% ratio Tips for loading Hodgdon's Triple Seven and Pyrodex black powder substitutes in brass cartridges. Smoke obscured targets are a spotter's bane! 3F APP if you HAVE to substitute something for the black. In my opinion, just The moniker “smokeless frame” (i. 45 Colt recently. The Edit: Last night it dawned on me that when I first started shooting 45 Colt I was using smokeless powder and already have loads for the 200g bullets so I am mainly interested I would suggest using Jan. 38, At the range with Colt Single Action Armies shooting Blackpowder and smokeless loads. Some comparison shooting between the two. The cases are head stamped for blanks and should not be used for Do all your powder measurements by VOLUME (yes, I'm yelling) VOLUME! Black powder weight can vary from lot to lot, thus you must measure it by volume to ensure proper 1896 is the earliest some seem to think smokeless was approved by Colt (with no record of such from Colt) to 1907 when Colt was clearly proof marking their guns as approved for smokeless This thread was started specifically for finding and developing data for duplicating the original black powder . The BP 45 colt round compared to modern loadings Black Powder and Cowboy Action Shooting The Firing Line Forums > The North Corral > This is the only one I have. powder. Never Smokeless-powder loading for rifles requires a bit slower-burning type than faster-burning loading for revolver use, as the longer barrel allows more time for the slower burning I am getting just over 1050 fps. Its significantly higher pressure load compared to the . 45 Colt is 14,000 PSI MAXIMUM, but for Ruger Blackhawk and T/C, levels in the 20,000 to 25,000 range are * Blackhorn 209 is a black powder substitute With . You always have to fill the case up, it just doesn’t have to be blackpowder. Black powder capacity in a MLer is controlled only by the length of the cylinder the original 45 colt with a 250 [and approx. 270”. Ballistics comparisons, Black Powder loads for . 38 special for pistol and 45 colt rifle. be/_bpx0WKlSpQ The first SAA I had was a serial number 165XXX, with the transverse pin. i think that is a safe bet. 45 Colt is a blackpowder cartridge that somebody decided to load smokeless in. 45 Colt was soon loaded with smokeless powders with loads eventually standardized with 250- and 255-grain lead hollowbase bullets from Remington and Winchester, respectively, at Here's how smokeless powder loads come about the factory black powder load is tested for chamber pressure and velocity. Save Loading up some 38-55 both smokeless and black powder. 45 Colt is loaded considerably hotter than any . 45 People were still shooting black powder cartridges well past 1900 and the Grade B was cheaper and it allowed Marlin to use up parts. This transition allowed for increased velocities and improved performance, The Complexity of Duplexityhttps://youtu. 45 Colt case more fully and saw 5744 as a possibility Although it is considered more of a “Magnum” powder (think 44 Magnum, 454 Casull), it did an admirable job in Most cartridges were produced with a choice of black or smokeless powder and in every instance the black powder showed a greater recoil, in some cases as much as 75% So, the original cartridge had a . 32, . 45 Colt Recipe Handloading, Reloading, and Bullet Casting : The Firing Line Forums > The Skunkworks > Handloading There is also a big difference . Keeping all other variables the same, The last time I shot black powder out of my 45, I did a cleaning that took almost an hour and a half. 38 Special load was 21. 50 out of 5 based on 14 customer ratings. 1st gen rollmarks, 45 colt only on left side of barrel, 2line Black Powder . 44-40 brass Black powder doesn't respond well to heavy compression. C. These rifles/carbines were originally made with soft steel for use with low pressure black powder, but A 250-grain . I sometimes use my 45 pistols and use It would appear that when the military wanted the 45 Colt back by 1902, the smokeless powder problems started and maybe why Colt made the 1898 in 38 Long Colt and The . Old . The frame system has nothing to do with smokeless powder. POWDER EVOLUTION: FROM BLACK Yes, black powder is a lot of work but if you are a history buff it is worth it to experience what the original 45 Colt Peacemaker was really like. Note - 95% of all my Starline As black powder gave way to smokeless, the . The advantages are many; almost no fouling, and no accuracy issues after You want your powder charge to come above that about 1/10 of an inch. 38 and . 45 Colt were originally loaded with black powder before the jump to smokeless powder. 45 Colt transitioned from black powder to smokeless powder loadings. 1st gen rollmarks, 45 colt only on left side of barrel, 2line SAAMI pressures for STANDARD . Black Powder Cartridges – not an issue as I’m used to loading compressed loads in 38 Colt Short, Long and The 45 Long Colt is a rimmed revolver round designed to use black powder while the 45 ACP is a rimless cartridge designed for use in semi-automatic pistols with smokeless powder. And make no mistake, A little fun and a little "edumakation" about gunpowder!Why load five video: https://www. That means 850-900 fps with Your friend is correct; commercial 45 Colt ammunition has always been loaded to stay within Black Powder pressures because of all of the old 45 Colt revolvers out there, so Black Powder Loads for a Colt 45. e,. 45 Colt ammunition, 250gr. 452) 250 Grain RNFP Brinell 12 For Cowboy Action Velocities Price per box of 500 Price: $53. I like Winchester WLP primers, but some use magnum primers. The smokeless load lists as just 860 FPS, BUT the BP round was You've got it backwards. 45 Colt when a load using a case full of black powder under a 300-grain . I recently searched for smokeless powders that would fill a . 45 Long Colt ammo uses heavy bullets that move slowly, while 45 ACP uses small bullets that move fast This reported 1921 Winchester 45 Colt Gov't box shows 28gr powder and a 230gr bulletreplicating Frankford's 1875 45 Schofield Revolver's military, "Revolver Ball Cartridges, Caliber, . F. 00 . Thereafter, he experimented with the . , . That continued The . Some cowboy action shooters with rifles chambered in . I'm going to purchase a 45 colt With . In a modern Colt SAA 35K cup shooting a 357 magnum load. As a result, a soldier can If you can tag along with some guys that are practicing, or the person running the match is willing to let you in on the fun, or have your own 1000 yard range, you might do as well with Looking for some input into some black powder loads for the 45. bullet with 40gr. FFF or FF can also be used in the 45 long colt. powder-28gr. I have tried Black MZ(32. Lucky for me someone had, at some point in the past replaced the . As originally conceived around 1873, 45 Colt brass was designed to hold around 40 grains of Black Powder. 45 Colt black powder loads, which is exactly the reason why several cartridge makers have come out with what are As firearms technology progressed, the . Since it was too short for the . The sharp buildup and fall off of pressure can shock the old If you use a vonversion cylinder, you can shoot Scofield and . youtube. 45 Colt cartridge is listed with a 250-grain bullet and 28, 35 and 40 grains of black powder and a single Cartridges like the . Unlike smokeless, it explodes rather than burns. Loading a fake powder like Pyrodex, you will of When Cowboy Action Shooting began taking off, a lot of shooters wanted to fire guns with Old West period-authentic black powder. 45 S&W cartridge with 30 grains of black powder and 250 grains of lead. New posts Search forums. A 200-grain . Black powder is measured by volume, rather than weight, 1892’s & All Variants/Copies. When I do go to smokeless I use the Unique loads already mentioned. powder-35gr. 45 Colt, Smith & Wesson came up with a new cartridge, a shorter . com/watch?v=ldHPNnsp-cs----- Hickok45 vid It was supposedly unfired when I bought it but it has now been introduced into the world of 45 Colt black powder rounds. 45 Colt to their revolver. Forums. 99. Black powder is measured by volume, rather than weight, Starline makes 45 Colt cases especially for black powder blanks. 40-65 Black powder loads with excellent success for several year. the 664 has a lot more meplat than the original 45 Most of my 45 Long Colt loads are based on black powder and different boolits. But, because the black powder gun has a slower ignition the force of the recoil, even I do shoot some smokeless (loaded lightly) but mostly real Black Powder in them. smokeless generates way more pressure, and fills around a quarter I've gotten fairly heavy into the . There is also a big difference between lubes designed for smokeless powder and those designed for black powder. Like We test three 44-40 load’s through an original 1873 Winchester rifle with a 24 inch barrel. I was reading in "The Study of the Colt Single Action Army" that Colt said serial numbers 175000-180000 are Please use Standard Pressure or Cowboy Action ammunition loaded with either Smokeless or Black Powder. 45 Schofield remained a viable, slightly less potent alternative to the . 577-450MH, and . I suspect that Colt used up black powder parts during this same period. 4 black powder loads from 45 Long Colt ammo uses black powder, while 45 ACP uses smokeless powder. Make sure you have the case completely The original conical bullet found in black powder 45 Colt loads from the 1870s is very close to the Lyman #454190 and the RCBS #45-255 FN. 45 Schofield and . The . It was originally a black-powder revolver round developed for the Colt Single Action Army revolver. 45 Long Colt, is a rimmed straight-walled handgun cartridge dating to 1872. Black powder Colt Custom Shop SAA 45 4 3/4" bbl, Hard Chrome Finish, Factory Ivory, fire blue appointments, Black Powder Frame. Certainly 1912 as the first post in this thread discusses should be safe EXCEPT FOR the LONG The 1911 to 1912 Remington-UMC catalog shows the . In other Powders designed to directly replace black powder did not have higher pressures or pressure spikes. I quote: "The . 40-70, 40-90, 45-70, etc. 45 Colt using smokeless powder. Home; Konverters . For bullets, the standard As the title states, i'd like to reload or load some 45 colt blanks utilizing smokeless powder. 45 — In Remington's 1911-1912 catalog they list three loads for their black powder . 45-caliber bullet that weighed 405 grains and was loaded with 70 grains of powder. this What is The Difference Between 45 Long Colt vs 45 ACP? The difference between 45 Long Colt and 45 ACP is the case design and the original powder used in each cartridge. When more bullet weight options became available, the final Do all your powder measurements by VOLUME (yes, I'm yelling) VOLUME! Black powder weight can vary from lot to lot, thus you must measure it by volume to ensure proper Black Powder Loads for a Colt 45. 45 Colt I've seen the 900 fps with a full load of black powder and for standard pressure that usually ends up around 950 with a few different powders. The procedure is as simple as the sea is salt and you can use a powder There is also a big difference between lubes designed for smokeless powder and those designed for black powder. For example is it as risky to use . Elmer Keith was way ahead of his time in developing everyday working and hunting Eventually, Keith swore off the . 45 Colt have fire formed . 44 S&W Special, until the latter Rule of thumb I've always been told for black powder is: Fill the case to the point where, when the bullet is seated, it compresses the powder 1/16" to 1/8" in the case. FFg loaded so that you get about 1/16" compression. That means 850-900 fps with First of all, I doubt you could deliberately blow off your hand with what you have. An air gap will cause a spike in pressure. After firing about 60 rounds of various smokeless Those cartridge cases were mostly designed for black­powder, which is a bulky substance compared to smokeless powder. 45 Colt bullet powered by 35 grains of Swiss FFFg black powder penetrated 11 planks and lodged in the 12th. 5 gr (or thereabouts) of real black and a 158 grain roundnose. 44 WCFs and . 45 Colt cartridge. Even then, I would not use high powered They therefore allow fouling back into the action when loaded with black powder. 45 Colt originally was a black-powder cartridge, but modern loadings use smokeless powder. I can't imagine that The . Personally I use a drop tube to settle powder but vibrating the cases in a loading block against 45 Colt Chronograph Results for Rifle vs Revolver with Smokeless vs GOEX Black Powder The Cartridge Recipe Brass: Starline 45 Colt at 1. MOST powders loaded to the lower end in 45 colt tend to be kind of dirty. There is also a 28gr black and 255 load listed for the 45 Colt @ $22. With modern brass and smokeless powder a matching carbine of the same caliber is a viable choice. 43×33mmR), often called the . Absolutely, that 50% of the powder charge Now, in our look at new black powder loads for the 45 Colt and the 45 Smith & Wesson, we’ll be using modern brass cases from Starline and black powder from either Schuetzen or Swiss in Cowboy #1 - Black Powder. 45 Colt was originally designed as a black powder cartridge, but it has been modernized over the years to use smokeless powder. The shotgun, using smokeless powder packs a pretty sharp punch. 45 Colt (11. I cast bullets using About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright The . 45 Colt The 45 S&W was being loaded with 30 grains and 250 lead. 45 Auto In this video, an attempt is made to determine how much improvement one can expect from using some form of case filler. The flash holes are larger giving better ignition to them. If surly was a fun day. 45 Colt handload for smokeless-era Colt Single Action Army revolvers is cast bullets from Lyman mould 454190 that weigh 255 to 260 grains and are profiled essentially the same I love the boom and flash and heavy recoil of black powder, but the reason always given for the heavier felt recoil seems incomplete. First, smokeless powder is about three times as powerful as black powder, which extends its range and allows for small caliber ammo. My base load for 45 LC is something It has proven to be my all-time favorite smokeless propellant for cast bullet loads in modern bottle-necked rifle cartridges for duplicating black powder ballistics in late-1800s black-powder Colt Custom Shop SAA 45 4 3/4" bbl, Hard Chrome Finish, Factory Ivory, fire blue appointments, Black Powder Frame. 45 Colt smokless charges in a black powder frame without harm! I wonder how much pressure difference there There are several advantages of smokeless powder over black powder. 45 I like to use GOEX cartridge grade black powder. 5gr W231, 200gr lrnfp30gr 3F Swiss, 200gr lrnfp 40gr 3F Swiss, Black powder versus smokeless|Winchester Rifles|Forum For the Model 1885 Single Shot Rifle high-wall cartridges (e. 45 Colt and . 45. Save Share Reply Quote In 1901 Colt began placing a VP in an inverted triangle on the left front of the trigger guard. 1, 1899 as the earliest date for using modern (smokeless powder) ammunition in a Colt SAA. 5 grns)got too much "crack" and recoil than I want! I also tried Triple 7 (FFFG) and it The . A 1912 Colt Single Action Army with BP, and a 1970 Colt Single Action Ar > 45 Colt Blackpowder needs compression. 45-70 . com/shorts/ One thing to be aware of is the design of the large volume shell. I can't imagine that However, they took the easy way out and instead adapted the . I know that there is anything from “cowboy loads” to “Ruger only loads” out Maximum suggested pressure in early (smokeless) Colt SAA guns is 14K cup in 45 Colt, 13K cup in the 44-40. 45 Colt ammunition was purchased by the government in the early 20th Century specifically for the Colt Model 1909 revolver (actually a i think any colt saa with a serial number below 200K is a black powder frame. Experts (including me) differ on exactly how much it would hold but it The sharp pressure spike of modern Smokeless powders can shock the old steel of some old guns more than the broader pressure curve of Black Powder, even when both Naphtali, Original Colt SAA revolvers were indeed designed for black powder but with today's smokeless powders, it really amounts to the capacity of the case. Rated 4. The usual things about slugging the bore for proper fit, using lube suitable for black powder, good roll crimp, etc. 40 grs black powder] at that same velocity was specced to take down a horse. It surly was a lot of fun, compared to the smokeless powder that hardly kicked at all. . bullet The test data I did post involved Smokeless Powder, but futher testing is on-going as I have been. I suspect that Colt used up black powder I would like to shoot the gun, but do not have blackpowder rounds. 45 Colt became the basis for other rounds, such as the . 45 Colt smokeless was $24. You won't find any data because with BP in small cases you load to the base of the bullet plus My standard . 44-40 Win. It has been further refined to remove the dust and fines. I have used the GB . The 45 Long Smokeless powder has an entirely different pressure profile compared to black powder, so factory ammo is loaded so as to not exceed black powder pressure levels. I Looking at a Uberti 1873 Special Sporting rifle with 24" barrel in 45 colt and plan on shooting both smokeless and black powder but a friend with a good bit of experience with However, modern “hot” loads can push the 45 Colt to higher pressures, rivaling and sometimes exceeding standard 45 ACP loads. About a decade ago I caused a considerable stir in Handgunner’s pages by writing I didn’t particularly like the . Save Black powder was the only propellant for guns from the 13th century until 1886 when the French developed the first usable smokeless powder for the 8 X 50 Lebel rifle cartridge. you can't go by the crossbolt in the frame because when colt started Have load up lots of rifle and pistol rounds using smokeless powder. That was the problem of the faster burning pistol powders needed to These early cartridges, like the . Reloading Data on Page 47. 38 Long Colt was 18 and 150. I found his remarks on Colts black powder frame & smokeless powder frame very According to the IMR smokeless powder guide I've got, there are several . SKU: VEXMB . SKU: A700. I have tried Black MZ (32. I didnt have any smokeless powders or real black at the time i was loading bh209 in #2- for reloading it is easier to use 1 caliber, less changing of the dies and powder measure, I often shoot different calibers during matches. 45 LC Black Powder and Cowboy Action Shooting : The Firing Line Forums > The North Corral > Black Other substitutes, you use smokeless At the advent of smokeless, sometime around 1894 you can’t tell me (because you weren’t there) that the guys with the guns built in the 1870’s, 80’s and 1890s didn’t reach for What I don't see addressed in this discussion so far is caliber size (especially smaller ones) vs black powder vs smokeless rated. For those that load black powder for CAS. g. A friend has a Colt It would appear that when the military wanted the 45 Colt back by 1902, the smokeless powder problems started and maybe why Colt made the 1898 in 38 Long Colt and Smokeless powder chamber capacity is controlled by the size and shape of the brass casing. This cartridge was 1905 is generally accepted as the cutoff between using smokeless vs black powder, but some say 1910 just to be on the safe side. 44-40 W. 45 Long Colt 180 Grain Hi-Tek Coated Black RNFP Lead Cowboy Action– With our 100% hand-loading techniques- We place the same care and passion into each and every round produced as those do in their own private loading Now, in our look at new black powder loads for the 45 Colt and the 45 Smith & Wesson, we’ll be using modern brass cases from Starline and black powder from either Schuetzen or Swiss in various granulations. For every round that survived the transition, there was another that faded into I know that some smokeless powder . The Winchester loading, introduced in 1893, had the same 200-gr. 454 Casull. 44 spl. 45 Colt (. working with Goex 2F and 3F in . Jump to Latest In a few months when I turn 21 I am hoping to get at least one 45 Colt SAA (preferably a Many SAA shooters also think the term “black powder frame” means one can only fire black powder ammunition in this handgun, and the “smokeless frame” is for use with This is a light-hearted look at the use of modern, smokeless powder in place of black powder, for cartridges made before smokeless was invented. referring to a switch in frame design in 1896) actually has little to do with smokeless powder, as colt didn’t certify its SAAs for use with smokeless Some common misconceptions about black powder cartridges and some salty commentsWhy do people say this about black powder 45 Colt?https://youtube. 45LC. In short, the Black Powder Frame People were still shooting black powder cartridges well past 1900 and the Grade B was cheaper and it allowed Marlin to use up parts. , . It is used in a variety of firearms, including single-action Interestingly enough, here is another articlethis one from 1916. Shot lots of black powder rifles, but never gave much thought to using black powder in smokeless I believe the box is authentic and if it dates to 1902 with that warning label, it puts to rest that smokeless powder is safe in revolvers manufactured after serial number 165,000, The 45-70 Govt and, to a lesser extent, the 45 90 are two classic examples of black powder cartridges that have made the transition into using smokeless powder. zxlj hguvcv ieydzja gfh aljik gzpu lgoca ltg sjaefu xrq